News & Notes

Week 4 in charts: Tetairoa McMillan leads the week, TE Cliff

Tetairoa McMillan led Week 4 with 45.2 PPR points. Jahmyr Gibbs and Jaxon Smith-Njigba lead their positions in value over replacement. Drake Maye is scoring under his usage.

ByMatt ThompsonNews & NotesOct 7, 20265 min read

Week 4 is in the books. Tetairoa McMillan (WR, CAR) put up 45.2 PPR points, the biggest line of the week, 3.9 clear of CeeDee Lamb. Through Week 4 the value leaders are Josh Allen at quarterback, Jahmyr Gibbs at running back, Jaxon Smith-Njigba at receiver and Brock Bowers at tight end.

Below: the week's scoreboard, the season leaders by value over replacement, where each position's cliff sits, who is scoring above or below his usage, who is rising and falling and who you can set and forget.

The Week 4 scoreboard

The top 12 in Week 4: 6 running backs and 6 receivers. 16 players cleared 25 points. The line to make this list was 26.7. Top of each position: QB Drake Maye (26.2), RB Kyren Williams (36.7), WR Tetairoa McMillan (45.2) and TE T.J. Hockenson (24.9).

Chart — Bar

Week 4 scoreboard

Top 12 PPR scores

Tetairoa McMillan · WR CAR: 45.2CeeDee Lamb · WR DAL: 41.3Kyren Williams · RB LA: 36.7Javonte Williams · RB DAL: 31.3Kenneth Walker III · RB KC: 30.9Nico Collins · WR HOU: 30.8

Leaders through Week 4

Josh Allen leads quarterbacks at +9.0 points a game above replacement (28.1 a game over 4 games), 3.0 clear of Brock Purdy. Jahmyr Gibbs leads running backs at +17.2 points a game above replacement (29.0 a game over 4 games), ahead of Kenneth Walker III by 1.5. Jaxon Smith-Njigba leads receivers at +18.3 points a game above replacement (29.2 a game over 4 games), ahead of CeeDee Lamb by 1.1. Brock Bowers leads tight ends at +12.2 points a game above replacement (24.1 a game over 2 games), 6.8 clear of Trey McBride.

Pos

Player

Team

PPG

VORP / game

GP

QB

Josh Allen

BUF

28.1

+8.96

4

QB

Brock Purdy

SF

25.1

+5.96

4

QB

Case Keenum

CHI

24.5

+5.32

1

RB

Jahmyr Gibbs

DET

29.0

+17.20

4

RB

Kenneth Walker III

KC

27.5

+15.73

4

RB

Bijan Robinson

ATL

26.4

+14.55

4

WR

Jaxon Smith-Njigba

SEA

29.2

+18.34

4

WR

CeeDee Lamb

DAL

28.1

+17.23

4

WR

Nico Collins

HOU

26.0

+15.18

2

TE

Brock Bowers

LV

24.1

+12.23

2

TE

Trey McBride

ARI

17.3

+5.43

4

TE

George Kittle

SF

16.1

+4.23

4

Value over replacement is points per game above the last startable player at the position, from actual game logs in PPR scoring.

Value cliffs

Replacement level, the last startable player at each position, sits at 19.2 PPR points a game at quarterback, 11.8 at running back, 10.8 at receiver and 11.9 at tight end. The elite separate most at receiver: Jaxon Smith-Njigba is 18.3 a game above that line, more than any other position's leader. The steepest cliff is at tight end: from Brock Bowers at +12.2 (TE1) to Trey McBride at +5.4 (TE2), a drop of 6.8 points a game. That is the tier line to draft or trade around.

Pos

Replacement (pts / game)

Leader (VORP / game)

Steepest drop in the top 12

QB

19.2

Josh Allen (+9.0)

QB1 Josh Allen → QB2 Brock Purdy (−3.0)

RB

11.8

Jahmyr Gibbs (+17.2)

RB3 Bijan Robinson → RB4 Derrick Henry (−3.7)

WR

10.8

Jaxon Smith-Njigba (+18.3)

WR3 Nico Collins → WR4 Amon-Ra St. Brown (−3.2)

TE

11.9

Brock Bowers (+12.2)

TE1 Brock Bowers → TE2 Trey McBride (−6.8)

Scoring above and below the usage

Over a season, scoring drifts back toward usage: the players furthest above their expected points tend to cool off, and the ones furthest below tend to catch up.

Running hot: Jaxon Smith-Njigba (WR, SEA) is scoring 9.9 points a game above what his usage says (19.2 expected, 29.0 actual); Zay Flowers (WR, BAL) is scoring 9.0 points a game above what his usage says (13.4 expected, 22.4 actual); Nico Collins (WR, HOU) is scoring 7.1 points a game above what his usage says (18.9 expected, 26.0 actual).

Owed points: Drake Maye (QB, NE) is scoring 8.0 points a game below what his usage says (20.0 expected, 11.9 actual); Cooper Rush (QB, ATL) is scoring 6.7 points a game below what his usage says (9.3 expected, 2.6 actual); Justin Herbert (QB, LAC) is scoring 6.5 points a game below what his usage says (17.3 expected, 10.9 actual).

Chart — Quadrant Scatter (interactive)

Expected vs actual fantasy points per game

The 50 most-fed players through Week 4

1015202530152025Identity line: actual equals expectedPunching above the roleEarning itNeither volume nor pointsOwed pointsJahmyr Gibbs: 27.2 Expected FP / game, 28.8 Actual FP / gameKenneth Walker III: 24.8 Expected FP / game, 27.5 Actual FP / gameTyler Shough: 23.1 Expected FP / game, 21.3 Actual FP / gameAshton Jeanty: 22.7 Expected FP / game, 18.5 Actual FP / gameCaleb Williams: 22.6 Expected FP / game, 22.5 Actual FP / gameJosh Allen: 22.3 Expected FP / game, 28.1 Actual FP / gameCeeDee Lamb: 22.2 Expected FP / game, 28 Actual FP / gameLamar Jackson: 22.2 Expected FP / game, 19.8 Actual FP / gameBryce Young: 22 Expected FP / game, 22.7 Actual FP / gameBrock Purdy: 21.9 Expected FP / game, 25.1 Actual FP / gameC.J. Stroud: 21.8 Expected FP / game, 17.1 Actual FP / gameAmon-Ra St. Brown: 21.6 Expected FP / game, 22.8 Actual FP / gameBrock Bowers: 21.6 Expected FP / game, 24.1 Actual FP / gameJoe Burrow: 21.1 Expected FP / game, 19.2 Actual FP / gameJared Goff: 20.9 Expected FP / game, 21.5 Actual FP / gameChris Olave: 20.8 Expected FP / game, 22.5 Actual FP / gameChristian McCaffrey: 20.8 Expected FP / game, 18.5 Actual FP / gameMatthew Stafford: 20.7 Expected FP / game, 15.4 Actual FP / gameDak Prescott: 20.6 Expected FP / game, 20.3 Actual FP / gameDerrick Henry: 20.2 Expected FP / game, 22.7 Actual FP / gameDrake Maye: 20 Expected FP / game, 11.9 Actual FP / gameDrake MayeBijan Robinson: 19.9 Expected FP / game, 26.3 Actual FP / gameTrey McBride: 19.8 Expected FP / game, 17.3 Actual FP / gameJavonte Williams: 19.6 Expected FP / game, 20.4 Actual FP / gameDeshaun Watson: 19.6 Expected FP / game, 16.7 Actual FP / gamePuka Nacua: 19.4 Expected FP / game, 20.1 Actual FP / gameJonathan Taylor: 19.3 Expected FP / game, 21.6 Actual FP / gameMichael Wilson: 19.2 Expected FP / game, 14.2 Actual FP / gameJaxon Smith-Njigba: 19.2 Expected FP / game, 29 Actual FP / gameJaxon Smith-NjigbaPatrick Mahomes: 19 Expected FP / game, 20.9 Actual FP / gameNico Collins: 18.9 Expected FP / game, 26 Actual FP / gameNico CollinsKyren Williams: 18.3 Expected FP / game, 22.4 Actual FP / gameTetairoa McMillan: 18.3 Expected FP / game, 18.6 Actual FP / gameD'Andre Swift: 18.2 Expected FP / game, 15.9 Actual FP / gameCase Keenum: 17.5 Expected FP / game, 24.5 Actual FP / gameJustin Herbert: 17.3 Expected FP / game, 10.9 Actual FP / gameJustin HerbertBaker Mayfield: 17.3 Expected FP / game, 11.7 Actual FP / gameAaron Rodgers: 17.2 Expected FP / game, 15.3 Actual FP / gameKirk Cousins: 17.1 Expected FP / game, 19.7 Actual FP / gameJordan Love: 17.1 Expected FP / game, 16.2 Actual FP / gameJayden Daniels: 17.1 Expected FP / game, 16.2 Actual FP / gameDavante Adams: 16.7 Expected FP / game, 18.2 Actual FP / gameGeno Smith: 16.6 Expected FP / game, 14.9 Actual FP / gameMalik Willis: 16.6 Expected FP / game, 10.4 Actual FP / gameTee Higgins: 16.4 Expected FP / game, 17.8 Actual FP / gameJalen Hurts: 16.3 Expected FP / game, 16.8 Actual FP / gameChase Brown: 16.2 Expected FP / game, 14.5 Actual FP / gameMatthew Golden: 16.1 Expected FP / game, 14.5 Actual FP / gameSam LaPorta: 15.9 Expected FP / game, 14.2 Actual FP / gameMichael Penix Jr.: 15.7 Expected FP / game, 13.4 Actual FP / gameExpected FP / game — → higher is betterActual FP / game — ↑ higher is better

Hover a dot for the full read-out, or click to pin it. Focus the chart and use arrow keys to step through.

  • Jahmyr Gibbs (DET · 4 games): Expected FP / game 27.2, Actual FP / game 28.8.
  • Kenneth Walker III (KC · 4 games): Expected FP / game 24.8, Actual FP / game 27.5.
  • Tyler Shough (NO · 4 games): Expected FP / game 23.1, Actual FP / game 21.3.
  • Ashton Jeanty (LV · 4 games): Expected FP / game 22.7, Actual FP / game 18.5.
  • Caleb Williams (CHI · 2 games): Expected FP / game 22.6, Actual FP / game 22.5.
  • Josh Allen (BUF · 4 games): Expected FP / game 22.3, Actual FP / game 28.1.
  • CeeDee Lamb (DAL · 4 games): Expected FP / game 22.2, Actual FP / game 28.
  • Lamar Jackson (BAL · 4 games): Expected FP / game 22.2, Actual FP / game 19.8.
  • Bryce Young (CAR · 4 games): Expected FP / game 22, Actual FP / game 22.7.
  • Brock Purdy (SF · 4 games): Expected FP / game 21.9, Actual FP / game 25.1.
  • C.J. Stroud (HOU · 4 games): Expected FP / game 21.8, Actual FP / game 17.1.
  • Amon-Ra St. Brown (DET · 4 games): Expected FP / game 21.6, Actual FP / game 22.8.
  • Brock Bowers (LV · 2 games): Expected FP / game 21.6, Actual FP / game 24.1.
  • Joe Burrow (CIN · 4 games): Expected FP / game 21.1, Actual FP / game 19.2.
  • Jared Goff (DET · 4 games): Expected FP / game 20.9, Actual FP / game 21.5.
  • Chris Olave (NO · 4 games): Expected FP / game 20.8, Actual FP / game 22.5.
  • Christian McCaffrey (SF · 4 games): Expected FP / game 20.8, Actual FP / game 18.5.
  • Matthew Stafford (LA · 4 games): Expected FP / game 20.7, Actual FP / game 15.4.
  • Dak Prescott (DAL · 4 games): Expected FP / game 20.6, Actual FP / game 20.3.
  • Derrick Henry (BAL · 4 games): Expected FP / game 20.2, Actual FP / game 22.7.
  • Drake Maye (NE · 4 games): Expected FP / game 20, Actual FP / game 11.9.
  • Bijan Robinson (ATL · 4 games): Expected FP / game 19.9, Actual FP / game 26.3.
  • Trey McBride (ARI · 4 games): Expected FP / game 19.8, Actual FP / game 17.3.
  • Javonte Williams (DAL · 4 games): Expected FP / game 19.6, Actual FP / game 20.4.
  • Deshaun Watson (CLE · 4 games): Expected FP / game 19.6, Actual FP / game 16.7.
  • Puka Nacua (LA · 2 games): Expected FP / game 19.4, Actual FP / game 20.1.
  • Jonathan Taylor (IND · 4 games): Expected FP / game 19.3, Actual FP / game 21.6.
  • Michael Wilson (ARI · 4 games): Expected FP / game 19.2, Actual FP / game 14.2.
  • Jaxon Smith-Njigba (SEA · 4 games): Expected FP / game 19.2, Actual FP / game 29.
  • Patrick Mahomes (KC · 4 games): Expected FP / game 19, Actual FP / game 20.9.
  • Nico Collins (HOU · 2 games): Expected FP / game 18.9, Actual FP / game 26.
  • Kyren Williams (LA · 4 games): Expected FP / game 18.3, Actual FP / game 22.4.
  • Tetairoa McMillan (CAR · 4 games): Expected FP / game 18.3, Actual FP / game 18.6.
  • D'Andre Swift (CHI · 4 games): Expected FP / game 18.2, Actual FP / game 15.9.
  • Case Keenum (CHI · 1 game): Expected FP / game 17.5, Actual FP / game 24.5.
  • Justin Herbert (LAC · 4 games): Expected FP / game 17.3, Actual FP / game 10.9.
  • Baker Mayfield (TB · 3 games): Expected FP / game 17.3, Actual FP / game 11.7.
  • Aaron Rodgers (PIT · 4 games): Expected FP / game 17.2, Actual FP / game 15.3.
  • Kirk Cousins (LV · 4 games): Expected FP / game 17.1, Actual FP / game 19.7.
  • Jordan Love (GB · 4 games): Expected FP / game 17.1, Actual FP / game 16.2.
  • Jayden Daniels (WAS · 2 games): Expected FP / game 17.1, Actual FP / game 16.2.
  • Davante Adams (LA · 4 games): Expected FP / game 16.7, Actual FP / game 18.2.
  • Geno Smith (NYJ · 4 games): Expected FP / game 16.6, Actual FP / game 14.9.
  • Malik Willis (MIA · 4 games): Expected FP / game 16.6, Actual FP / game 10.4.
  • Tee Higgins (CIN · 4 games): Expected FP / game 16.4, Actual FP / game 17.8.
  • Jalen Hurts (PHI · 4 games): Expected FP / game 16.3, Actual FP / game 16.8.
  • Chase Brown (CIN · 4 games): Expected FP / game 16.2, Actual FP / game 14.5.
  • Matthew Golden (GB · 4 games): Expected FP / game 16.1, Actual FP / game 14.5.
  • Sam LaPorta (DET · 4 games): Expected FP / game 15.9, Actual FP / game 14.2.
  • Michael Penix Jr. (ATL · 2 games): Expected FP / game 15.7, Actual FP / game 13.4.
50 plotted4 groupsIdentity line shown

Expected fantasy points are what a player’s targets, carries and situations would score for a league-average player. Below the line is scoring under the usage; above it is running hot.

Rising and falling

Comparing the last two weeks with the season average, Drake London is the biggest riser at 21.5 a game against a 14.3 average (+7.2), and Josh Allen the biggest faller at 18.0 against 28.1 (−10.1). Two weeks is a lean, not a verdict; check the usage before you act on it.

Rising

Player

Last 2

Season

Δ

Drake London WR · ATL

21.5

14.3

+7.2

Aaron Rodgers QB · PIT

22.4

15.3

+7.1

Michael Wilson WR · ARI

21.2

14.2

+7.0

Kyren Williams RB · LA

29.3

22.4

+6.8

Sam Darnold QB · SEA

20.5

13.8

+6.7

Falling

Player

Last 2

Season

Δ

Josh Allen QB · BUF

18.0

28.1

−10.1

Amon-Ra St. Brown WR · DET

13.7

22.8

−9.1

Dalton Kincaid TE · BUF

2.8

11.5

−8.8

Jalen Coker WR · CAR

9.2

17.4

−8.2

Justin Jefferson WR · MIN

6.8

15.0

−8.1

Set-and-forget, and swing plays

Among starters averaging 10 or more, Chris Olave, Kyren Williams and Jalen Hurts bust the least, and Deshaun Watson, Aaron Rodgers and Ja'Marr Chase boom the most. Floor and ceiling are a bad week and a big week from the actual scores, not a projection.

Rarely bust

Player

PPG

Boom

Bust

Floor

Ceiling

Chris Olave WR · NO

22.5

25%

0%

19.6

28.2

Kyren Williams RB · LA

22.4

25%

0%

15.5

36.7

Jalen Hurts QB · PHI

16.8

25%

0%

12.6

24.7

Boom or bust

Player

PPG

Boom

Bust

Floor

Ceiling

Deshaun Watson QB · CLE

16.7

50%

25%

12.9

20.3

Aaron Rodgers QB · PIT

15.3

50%

25%

4.0

22.7

Ja'Marr Chase WR · CIN

15.1

50%

25%

3.2

26.5

Use it

  • Rank across positions on one scale with the VORP board, and reach for the position whose cliff comes first.

  • Buy the players scoring under their usage and sell the ones running hot on the expected points board.

  • Put any two to four players side by side, week by week, in Deep Research.

  • Every chart here lives on the analytics dashboard, filtered by season, scoring and position.

More from this author

Matt Thompson

View all